Skip to content

The Pakatan Rakyat Manifesto: A manifesto for its time – Anas Alam Faizli

March 20, 2013

The Pakatan Rakyat Manifesto: A manifesto for its time

Political preference aside, there is cause to applaud the recent Pakatan Rakyat Manifesto. Tackling core economic issues, its four pillars hit home the concerns of the common rakyat; fraternity of the people, the people’s economy, people’s well-being and people’s government.

In Malaysia, the published absolute poverty number may be low, but in relative terms, many rakyat including daily creation of urban poor are effectively impoverished by demanding cost of housing and living that are unmatched by salary levels, high indebtedness, and low productivity levels due to limited skills and education.

For the government to maintain relevance in the face of libertarian claims, government interventions need to be tactical. If the government’s stance is pro-business, it must be backed-up with robust social safety nets to hoist up and bring along poor households in the sprint towards growth and wealth creation.

If the focus is the rakyat, care must be put to ensure business appetite is not suppressed. Such aspirations will be impossible to achieve without policies such as those proposed by the PR Manifesto; such as expanded educational opportunities (by making tertiary education free), reduction in the cost of living (utilities and tolls), targeted instead of blanket subsidies, and an upward pressure towards wages and salaries that are currently depressed by influx of foreign labour.

We have yet to see what Barisan Nasional has to promise with its manifesto but as a start, it should be more defined than its 2008 one; “to grow the economy” and start quantifying them. In fact, growing the economy is really a given.

Uplifting the poor: Levelling the playing field

This is no plan to pull a modern-day Robin Hood, robbing the rich off of their hard work to reassign some wealth to the poor. The rich may be reached out to, to shoulder some responsibility to raise the level of education, health and productivity of the poor.

Imagine the difference between a community with a billionaire worth RM40 billion and lots of poor people, versus one with 400 households worth RM10.0 million each. We might not love to pay tax but we accept its legitimacy as long as it is properly enacted into law and is used properly.

This by no means entails slacking off on the part of the poor. Opportunities are provided, but they still need to be capitalized upon. The idea is a bigger economic pie and an unleashing of further values that the poorer population could have produced and Malaysia could have enjoyed.

Putting all these into consideration, where does it leave libertarianism, minimal taxes to the rich and businesses, and the free market? Need bigger government roles necessarily mean bigger inefficiencies, and more corruption?

Welfare states in Scandinavia have ranked higher than America in terms of the Human Development Index (HDI). At the same time, Scandinavian nations are among the most equal nations, high in governance and control over corruption, despite the bigger size of their government.

Ultimately, a healthy economy is a mixed economy, in which both the government and market forces both play their role. The exact balance remains an ongoing battle; but it’s good to start with unravelling the realities of inequality. Inequality is neither a hobby for anti-capitalist activists, nor development economists looking for the next trendy topic for their thesis. It’s true that government intervention in the shapes and sizes that they take form, may have distortive capabilities, but the “lazy poor and the hardworking rich” is a myth. For a better Malaysia, we have no choice but to continue our strive for productivity albeit with a new focus; inclusiveness.

Otherwise, Malaysia will be dragging its feet into the future, carrying the baggage of the past policies and its repercussions.

“A statesman is he who thinks in the future generations, and a politician is he who thinks in the upcoming elections.” ~ Abraham Lincoln

* Anas Alam Faizli is an oil and gas professional. He is pursuing a post-graduate doctorate, executive director of TFTN and tweets at @aafaizli

Read the entire article here with the title …The Myth of Rich and Poor, free market, libertarians ad The PR Manifesto.

Advertisements
One Comment leave one →
  1. najib manaukau permalink
    March 21, 2013 5:22 am

    Trying to talk or to reason to this bunch of scumbags and parasites from Umno is just like trying to talk or reason to the snakes. Will these Umno morons ever get to know or understand what you are trying to convey to them ? It will be just a waste of time, just kick them out of Putrajaya in the coming GE, if there is going to be one, and have them replaced by the opposition. The present opposition members are not what I would call members that I would want or want or wish to have as the replacement. At the least half a loaf is better than none. The present regime has proven they are not someone who can be trusted, they are given more than five decades to prove their worth and just look what has taken place. The country is heavily in debt and the million poor Malays are no better off than they were before these scumbags and parasites took control of the country.
    No doubt and for sure the warlords of Umno are very wealthy now and even have money hidden in foreign banks but the Malays are supposed to be more than 50% of the population which should come to over 13 million of them.
    Most of the warlords are not real Malays, just like the grand son of the pariah from Kerala, the shenanigan Mahathir and his children. Although they would swear on their grand mothers’ grave that they are, they are mamak, or at best Umno made Malays, period. They are adamantly claiming to be Malays for the privileges and the rights accorded to the Malays and above all they just want to rob and steal in the name of being Malays. Take away such rights and privileges they would swear they are not Malays yesterdays and most of all not even muslims. These scumbags and parasites really are a bloody disgrace to the real Malays ! Therefore wake up Malays don’t be fooled by these Umno made Malays and kick them out of Putrajaya in the coming GE ! In no time soon after they are kicked out of Putrajaya they will claim to be anyone other than Malay muslims ! Please remember the grand children of the shenanigan Mahathir already has more Chinese blood in them now. Isn’t that a good indication of what he is already planning for his descendants to be. What a bloody shamble, from a pariah from Kerala, to a Malay then to a Chinese in a matter of a few generations !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: