PSC report unscientific, says PAS’ nuke expert

Teoh El Sen (FMT) | June 20, 2012

KUALA LUMPUR: Hulu Langat MP Che Rosli Che Mat has rejected claims that he broke ranks with his PAS colleagues by saying that the Lynas plant was safe.
He said he had consistently stated that radiation levels at the plant were low, but added that this was not the same as saying Lynas’ operations did not threaten the health of the Gebeng community.

“Yes, external radiation is really low,” he told a press conference. “As a nuclear scientist, I know about radiation, but when it comes to safety of chemical handling and waste management, these are issues that need to be given attention by other experts.”
He said the government should not yet give Lynas a temporary operating licence, disagreeing with one of the 31 recommendations of the parliamentary select committee that the Dewan Rakyat accepted yesterday.
He recommended that Lynas conduct a lab simulation to determine the amount of radioactive residues its plant would produce and to take radiation readings.
He added that Lynas should also show how it would treat the wastes from its operations before releasing them into a nearby river.
“We need a lab scale, not a TOL,” he said. “We need a simulation so we know the real impact on health.
“The PSC has done a good job of collating all the problems and concerns of the public, but the answers are not complete.”
He said the lab simulation would take only two months to conduct and the cost would not be high.
“Without more data, the PSC was too quick to come to a conclusion, compared to the Atomic Energy Licensing Board (AELB).”
He said the PSC failed to address public concerns adequately with empirical facts.
“There are no statistics on the Bukit Merah rare earth plant, on the correlations between cancer cases and the plant. I’m sure AELB has the data.
“I also see that my friends—scientists—testified for the committee, but I could not find any answers from them that could be considered scientific in the report.
“So I can’t accept all of the PSC recommendations. There are problems.”
BN MPs have been using Che Rosli’s statement about low radiation levels in Gebeng as evidence that some opposition politicians were not against the controversial Lynas plant.

2 thoughts on “PSC report unscientific, says PAS’ nuke expert

  1. Che Rosli is claiming to be a nuclear scientist, to begin with what is a nuclear scientist involves in politic ? Also it is because of this sort of nuclear scientist that Malaysia is in what they are. Malaysia is taking on a project the Australian does not want in their own back yard, or is in Australia they can’t find nuclear scientist as good as you are, hence they are building the plant in Malaysia ?
    Low radiation, however low it may be, it is still radiation, are you saying that it is acceptable to have low radiation ? Just like the chief of PSC is saying he has no problem staying next to the plant, he knows damn well he is based in K.L. and in no circumstances he will ever need to stay near the plant. The real truth that he is saying that is for Najib to keep him as the boss of PSC but he forgot that shortly when the opposition takes over Putrajaya he will no doubt be one of the first to be replaced.

  2. The PSC is just another eyewash. The details released by the PSC is half-truth. The whole thing is plain bunkum. But then again, we have a bunkum govt. Vote Pakatan for a better future. Throw BN and their bunkum into the ditch.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s