Three opposition MPs are to raise issues related to controversial multi-billion ringgit procurements when they meet with Defence Minister Ahmad Zahid Hamidi tomorrow, on his invitation.
The representatives are DAP’s Petaling Jaya Utara MP Tony Pua (left in photo), PKR’s Machang MP Saifuddin Nasution and PAS’ Kuala Selangor MP Dzulkefly Ahmad (right in photo).
The RM9 billion contract with Boustead Naval Shipyards for six littoral combatant ships (frigate class) is expected to feature in the discussions.
“The contract was signed despite the defence minister having told Parliament, twice in March last year, that the ceiling price set for the acquisition of these ships was RM6 billion,” Pua said in a statement this morning.
“This represents a huge increase of RM3 billion or 50 percent of the original budget.”
Scandal-hit company to build warships
Pua said Malaysians were even more concerned when Boustead announced that the ships would be built by scandal-ridden French warship manufacturer DCNS.
DCNS had been convicted by a French court of bribing Taiwanese officials and fined RM2.5 billion.
The company supplied Malaysia two Scorpene submarines, costing RM6.5 million, and has allegedly paid its local agent Perimekar Sdn Bhd RM500 million to for “coordination and support services”.
One of Perimekar’s shareholders is the wife of political analyst Abdul Razak Baginda (left), who is closely linked to Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak, who was defence minister at the time of the Scorpene purchase.
Abdul Razak was one of three people charged with the gruesome murder of Mongolian national Altantuya Shariibuu, who acted as a translator in the Scorpene procure deal, but was released without his defence being called.
Locally-based human rights NGO Suaram has filed a case in the French court against DCNS for allegedly paying kickbacks to Malaysian government officials for the submarine purchase. The payment of commissions for such deals is illegal under French law.
Pua also said that Zahid must also explain the RM7.55 billion purchase of 257 armoured personnel carriers, each of which cost RM29.4 million.
Deftech Sdn Bhd, a subsidiary of DRB-Hicom Bhd, owned by a businessman closely linked to Umno – Syed Mokhtar Al Bukhary – has purchased the “base system” for the carriers from Turkish defence company FNSS Defence Systems for about RM1.7 billion or RM6.7 million each.
Last month, Zahid (right) invited Pua and Kita president Zaid Ibrahim to meet him so he could answer their queries over the purchase of the patrol vessels, also known as littoral combat ships (LCS).
Zahid, however, questioned where Pua got his information that the total cost of the six vessels had gone up from RM6 billion to RM9 billion.
Said Pua: “The minister must be transparent about this procurement, especially since it was not done by open tender.
“The government must provide details of equipment and services which makes the difference between the acquisition cost of RM7.55 billion relative to the base system of only RM1.7 billion.”
He reiterated his call to the government to set up a Parliamentary Oversight Committee to review and to ensure greater accountability and transparency in the country’s defence procurements.
Media Statement by Tony Pua, DAP National Publicity Secretary and Member of Parliament for Petaling Jaya Utara in Kuala Lumpur on Wednesday, 18 January 2012
Pakatan Rakyat MPs will meet up with Dato’ Seri Zahid Hamidi to meet up tomorrow to seek clarifications for recent defence acquisition controversies and to push for the set up of a Parliamentary Oversight Committee on Defence Procurement
Pakatan Rakyat Member of Parliaments, Saifuddin Nasution, Dr Dzulkefli Ahmad and myself will meet with Dato’ Seri Zahid Hamidi tomorrow 19th January 20112 (Thursday) at 3 pm at the Ministry of Defence after receiving his invitation to discuss the recent controversies with regards to defence procurement.
Among the issues which we will raise with the Minister is the contract signed by the Ministry of Defence with Boustead Naval Shipyards “to design, construct, equip, install, commission, integrate, test and trials, and deliver six Littoral Combatant Ships (Frigate Class)” for the amount of RM9 billion last month.
The RM9 billion contract was signed despite the Minister of Defence having told the Parliament twice in March last year that the ceiling price set for the acquisition of these ships was set at RM6 billion. This represents a huge increase of RM3 billion or 50% of the original budget.
Malaysians are even more concerned when Boustead announced that the ships will be built by scandal-ridden French warships manufacturer, DCNS. While the ship-building history and capabilities of DCNS are not in doubt – DCNS has been found guilty of bribing government officials in Taiwan and has been fined by the Courts €630 million (approximately RM2.5 billion).
The Taiwanese government has continued its litigation against DCNS by filing another NT$ 3.0 billion (~RM310 million) in additional compensation from DCNS, above and beyond the sum above, for prohibited commissions and kickbacks at the International Court of Arbitration.
Malaysians are of course well aware of the €115 million (~RM500 million) paid to Perimekar Sdn Bhd for “coordination and support services” in the Malaysia’s purchase of 2 Scorpene submarines from DCNS which cost €1.34 billion (~RM6.5 billion). Perimekar was owned by the Prime Minister and the then Defence Minister Dato’ Seri Najib Razak’s close associate, Abdul Razak Baginda. It was also a newly set up company with no prior experience in providing defence support and coordination services.
The Ministry of Defence must also provide clarity over the RM7.55 billion purchase of 257 armoured personnel carriers at RM29.4 million each. It has been publicised widely that Deftech Sdn Bhd, a subsidiary of DRB-Hicom Bhd owned by Tan Sri Syed Mokhtar Al Bukhary which was awarded the contract, has purchased the “base system” from Turkish defence company, FNSS Defence Systems for approximately US$559 million (~RM1.7 billion or RM6.7 million each).
The Minister must provide transparency over the above procurement, especially since it was conducted without any open tender. The Government must provide details of equipment and services which makes the difference between the acquisition cost of RM7.55 billion relative to the “base system” of only RM1.7 billion.
Most importantly, given the size, specialisation and sensitivity of defence procurement, we would like to repeat our call for the Malaysian government to set up the Parliamentary Oversight Committee on Defence Procurement modelled after the United States House Oversight Subcommittee on National Security, Homeland Defense and Foreign Operations which looks after defence policies as well as the US Defense Budget Appropriation Committees which review and approve detailed defence expenditure.
The set up of the Parliamentary Oversight Committee on Defence Procurement will lead to greater accountability and transparency to ensure that the rakyat’s wealth will not be frittered away, especially in the light of the warning by Datuk Idris Jala that Malaysia might be bankrupt by 2019 if Government expenditure is not curtailed.